July 16, 2024

MCSF Committee Instructions

Process

  • Each application will be a PDF file with an ID number in the filename.
  • The PDF file will contain a cover letter, transcript, letter of recommendation (optional), and an essay (650 word limit).
  • An effort is made to redact the applicant’s identity.
  • The individuals on the screening committee are asked to identify the 15 applications that they like the most. Then rank them from #1 (best) down to #15.
  • A value of 15 points is assigned to your #1 application, 14 points to #2, … and so on with #15 receiving 1 point.
  • All submissions by the screening committee are combined to provide a composite ranked list recommendation.

Guidelines

  • Ranking of applications must be without regard to race, gender, religion, political beliefs, or any other factors, which could constitute unfair or illegal discrimination.
  • Selection and ranking of the 15 applications are based on your overall judgement of the applications, and those portions of the application you value most. This will be different for each member of the screening committee.
  • Selection and ranking should be an individual exercise without a discussion of the applications with others before the due date.
  • Rank applications from #1 (Best) down to #15
  • Submit application rankings using the application ID number

Timeline

  • February 15th – Acceptance required from MCSF screening committee.
  • March 15th – Published cut-off for submission of scholarship applications.
  • March 16th – Preparation of scholarship applications for committee.
  • March 17th – Publication of scholarship applications to the committee.
  • April 15th – Due date for screening committee rankings.

Letters of Recommendation

  • Students are provided 3 options regarding letters of recommendation
    • Submit application without letter
    • Upload PDF file with application
    • Letter coming to MCSF per requirements
      (MCSF sends a solicitation email to the person identified by the student.)
  • A letter of recommendation is optional, and absence of one does not disqualify the application.

Essays

Using AI tools to write application essays is becoming more common. Each individual committee member may independently determine for themselves if they suspect that an essay was not written by the student, and decide how much this suspicion will impact that committee member’s selection and ranking of the application.